Why the Right Choice Between Fixed and Removable Bollards Could Save You Thousands 

Choosing between fixed and removable bollards is one of the most important security decisions property owners make. In Melbourne and Geelong, the wrong choice can cost thousands in replacements, downtime, and insurance risks. Fixed bollards provide permanent strength. Removable bollards add flexibility. Knowing when to use each protects both money and property.

The Hidden Cost of Choosing the Wrong Bollard

The most expensive bollards are often the ones installed twice. Once concrete has been poured, changing from fixed to removable, or the other way around, means:
  • Cutting through existing foundations
  • Paying for demolition and disposal
  • Re-pouring concrete and re-installing
  • Losing time while areas are closed off
Businesses may face more than construction costs. If a roller door is blocked, deliveries stall. If bollards don’t meet council rules, compliance fines follow. If insurance standards aren’t met, claims may be rejected.
Cheap imports are another trap. They often:
  • Rust after the first few winters
  • Fail under repeated use
  • Use weak locks that don’t last
  • Offer no compliance guarantee
Josh Ploeger, owner of First Choice Bollards, explains:
“We often get called in to replace bollards after only a couple of years. It’s usually because the wrong type was chosen or the product was too cheap to last. Spending a bit more upfront can prevent thousands in rework later.”

When Fixed Bollards Are the Right Answer

Fixed bollards are permanent and uncompromising. They are suited to sites where vehicles must never be allowed through.

Common uses include:

Retail storefronts:
Protection against ram raids

Warehouses:
Securing roller doors and access points

Utility and infrastructure sites:
Compliance and safety protection

Car parks and footpaths:
Permanent separation of vehicles and pedestrians

For high-security environments, fixed bollards are the most cost-effective choice in the long run.

When Removable Bollards Make More Sense

Not every site needs a permanent barrier. Some require secure access one day and open access the next. Removable bollards provide that flexibility without compromising strength.

They are most valuable in:

  • Shared driveways:
    Residents can block unauthorised parking but still allow access
  • Workshops and dealerships:
    Bollards protect roller doors at night and allow trade by day
  • Car yards and forecourts:
    Space can be opened for sales and closed for security
  • Event spaces and markets:
    Access changes depending on the activity
High-quality removable bollards offer:
  • Lockable, tamper-proof systems
  • Flush covers to remove trip hazards
  • Australian steel designed for local conditions
  • Standard diameters like 90mm and 114mm for strength
Installed correctly, they can provide protection comparable to fixed options, with the added benefit of access control.

Details That Buyers Often Miss

Choosing between fixed and removable bollards is only the start. Mistakes are often made in the details.
  • Compliance: Council approvals and insurance requirements must be met
  • Depth of installation: Shallow foundations weaken even the strongest bollard
  • Locking systems: Low-quality locks make removable bollards vulnerable
  • Steel thickness and grade: Imported thin-walled products often fail early
These factors are easy to overlook but make the difference between a bollard that lasts 20 years and one that fails in two.

Why the Right Choice Saves Money

The cost of bollards is not just the purchase price. The right choice at the start delivers savings in:
  • Avoided retrofits: No need to replace and re-install later
  • Reduced downtime: Businesses stay open and operational
  • Insurance benefits: Demonstrating stronger protection can lower premiums
  • Property protection: Damage from vehicles is less likely
Owners who get it right the first time protect both their property and their bottom line.

Why First Choice Bollards Leads in Melbourne and Geelong

First Choice Bollards has built its reputation on strength, compliance, and local expertise.
  • Australian-made steel: Built for Australian conditions, not overseas imports
  • Professional installation: Meeting council and insurance standards from day one
  • Proven track record: Protecting homes, workshops, car yards, and large commercial sites
  • Full range: Fixed, removable, surface-mounted, and custom solutions available

For flexible access and lasting protection, see their Removable Bollards range.

FAQs on Fixed vs Removable Bollards

Fixed bollards are permanent. Removable bollards can be unlocked and taken out when access is needed.

Fixed bollards are cheaper where access is never required. Removable bollards are smarter where controlled access is necessary.

Yes, if they use quality locks and are set in deep foundations.

Often they do, particularly in commercial or public areas.

DIY installations often fail compliance and may not withstand impact. Professional installation is recommended.

Choosing the wrong type of bollard for the site, leading to costly replacements.

TRADING HOURS

Monday – Friday
  • 8:00am – 5:00pm
Saturday
  • 9:00am – 12:00pm
Sunday
  • Closed

HAVE QUESTIONS?

Have Questions?
Call Us

CONNECT WITH US

@ 2025 First Choice Bollards. ABN 90 685 661 833. All rights reserved. Web Design by CJ Digital